Sabine Hossenfelder (see
this) told that 4.8 sigma evidence for B meson anomaly manifesting itself in the decays of B meson to K
* meson plus muon pair has been reported (see
this).
1. What is known?
Below is the abstract of the article telling about the finding.
An analysis of the decay amplitudes of B0; K*0→ K+π -μ +μ - is presented, using proton-proton collision data recorded by the LHCb experiment at centre-of-mass energies of 7, 8, and 13 TeV, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 8.4 fb-1. The amplitudes are constructed from Legendre polynomials in the μ+μ+ invariant mass squared region 1.1 < q2< 8.0 GeV2/c4. CP-averaged observables are obtained from the amplitudes.
Some of these observables present deviations with respect to the Standard Model, which can be interpreted as shifts in the effective Wilson coefficients. This model-independent approach enables tests of theoretical predictions that can help disentangle hadronic effects from potential contributions from physics beyond the Standard Model. This allows flexibility in the choice of q2 binning for global analyses. Depending on the binning scheme, the deviation of the Wilson coefficient C9 from its Standard Model expectation varies from 4.3σ to 4.8σ.
A large variety of models explaining the B meson anomaly have been proposed.
- Perhaps the simplest model for the anomaly is in terms of a heavier partner Z' of Z0 boson.
The anomaly reduces to that associated with the vertex involving a transformation of the b quark to s quark by CKM mixing by the emission of Z' boson.
- Since a very short distance phenomenon is in question this can be approximately described in effective QFT approach by a purely local interaction terms as product of the neutral weak current involving b and s quark and muon pair. This description is completely analogous to the description of weak interactions in terms of the four-fermion vertex in the original Fermi model.
- As in the Fermi model, the interaction term is space-time integral for the product of weak currents involving Z' propagator proportional to the inverse mass squared of Z' having spatial dimension 2. The spatial dimension of the product of weak fermion currents coefficient of is determined by d=-6. In the parameterization the mass squared gives a proportionality constant proportional to cutoff mass squared 1/μ 2. The index of C9 is a convention for labelling various non-local interaction terms of the effective action of the standard model. There is no perturbative expansion since effective action is in question and the interaction term gives a simplified description for the loops responsible for the appearance of heavier particles in the interaction vertex making possible the anomaly.
Google Gemini informs that there are two kinds of models possibly explaining the anomaly in terms of Z
'. If the Z
' gauge coupling is comparable to the Standard Model electroweak couplings g
Z' ∼ 0.1 - 1.0, global fits to the b → l
+l
- data typically restrict its mass to the range (1-7) TeV. Why this range?
- The lower bound is ∼ 1-2 TeV: direct searches at ATLAS and CMS rule out lighter Z' bosons. If Z' were lighter than this and coupled directly to muons, it would have already appeared as a striking resonant "peak" in dimuon μ+μ- invariant mass distributions at the LHC.
- The Upper Bound ∼ 5-7 TeV: If the mass is any higher, its effect on the low-energy Wilson coefficients C9 would become too weak to explain the observed deviations in B-meson decays, unless the couplings are artificially dialed up to mathematically unstable levels.
If the couplings are allowed to be much larger (approaching the perturbative limit where quantum field theory calculations remain reliable), the Z
' can hide at much higher energy scales: M
Z' ∼ 10-30 TeV
In this scenario, a heavy Z
' is too massive to be directly produced at the LHC, but its virtual "ghost" signature would still be heavy enough to generate the required modifications to the Wilson coefficients. Testing a Z
' in this range requires future facilities like the Future Circular Collider (FCC) or a high-energy muon collider.
2. What could TGD say about the B anomaly?
TGD predicts a hierarchy of scale up copies of the standard model physics. p-Adic length scale hypothesis involves the conjecture is that these copies are labelled by 3 kinds of Mersenne primes: ordinary Mersenne primes Mk =2k-1, Gaussian Mersennes MG,k =(1+i)k-1 and Eisensteinian Mersenne primes (see this). Ordinary hadron physics correspond to M107 =2107-1, there is evidence for M89 hadron physics, which would be the scaled up version of ordinary hadron physics with 512 times higher mass scale and also for the MG,79 hadron physics with mass scale higher by a factor 214. The next candidate would be M61 hadron physics with mass scale higher by factor 223. Therefore MG,79 remains the only option.
Ordinary weak bosons correspond to M89 and this would mean that for MG,79 weak physics, the mass scales of weak bosons are by a factor 32 higher than for the standard model weak interactions. For the scaled up version of the ordinary Z0 boson with mass .09 TeV this would predict a mass M= 2.88 TeV. This mass belongs to the region allowed by coupling strength which are of same scale as for the standard model.
2.1 What guesses can one make about the new bosons possibly explaining the B anomaly?
- Google Gemini informs that if the couplings are in the range .1-1 for weak couplings needed for perturbation theory the mass of the new boson is in the range 1-5 TeV. There is an estimate of 2.9 TeV for the mass of the new boson.
- TGD predicts a hierarchy of standard model physics. Weak interactions correspond to the p-adic scale associated with the Mersenne prime M89. The next p-adic length scale corresponds to MG,79. The scaling Z0 mass from M89 to MG,79 by factor 32= 2(89-79)/2 gives mass of 2.88 TeV, which is rather near to the empirical estimate. MG,79 is the only possibility since the next candidate M61 would give a huge mass.
- For this option the universality of quark and lepton couplings is the first guess. There are however indications for the violation of fermion universality and TGD allows us to consider a model explaining these violations (see this and this).
Google Gemii however informs that the claimed violation of the lepton universality is thought to be due a measurement error.
2.2. What could happen in the transformation of b quark to s quark?
Consider first what might happen the creation of a muon pair as b quark transforms to s quark.
- The decay of B meson to muon pair or to K* and muon pair induced by the transformation of b quark to s quark. The direct coupling b → s vanishes. Since neutral-current couplings are diagonal. CKM mixing for charged-current couplings involving the emission of a virtual W boson makes possible the b-s coupling via radiative corrections. Therefore a radiative correction involving emission of virtual W bosons must be involved.
- Upon the emission of a W boson, the b quark temporarily transforms into a c, u, or t quark. This W boson is then absorbed and i by CKM mixing gives rise to say s quark. The virtual W boson emits an MG,79 photon (γ79) or Z0 boson Z79, which subsequently decays into, say, a muon pair. This gives a small correction to the production rate predicted by the standard model.
If only only Z is replaced with dark Z
79 and W
79 and heavy quark are ordinary, this picture fails.
- If the mass of the heaviest quark is that of the "official" t quark, and W bosons have their ordinary masses, the amplitude for the pair production is proportional to the square of t/Z mass ratio scaled by factor 2-10 and very small. This is in a dramatic conflict with the finding that the amplitude is reduced by about 25-30 percent.
- The basic question is whether the transition to MG,79 phase can occur for all weak bosons and the also for the "official" t quark. For the "official" t quark assumed to have k=107, this would require scaling of the mass by 214 but only a scaling by factor 32 is required. Therefore only the identification of the "official" t quark as M89 u quark is possible in the TGD framework.
If this the case, the amplitude for the production of lepton pair is not changed much since only the ratio of the masses of u79, W79 and Z79 appear in the amplitude and they are same as in the standard physics. This option seems to be the only possible one and supports the identification of the real to as Aleph quark with mass of 28 GeV and of "official" t quark as u quark of M89 hadron physics.
Note that the scaling of the mass of the "official" top quark gives a mass of 342 MeV, which is 10 percent higher than the constituent masses of the u and d quark in proton. Also this encourages the interpretation of top as M89 u quark. The mass of the constituent s quark is 486 MeV. This would scale by factor 512 to 249 GeV.
For the MG,79 counterparts of pion, kaon and eta, the masses would be 2.3 TeV, 8.2 TeV and 8.9 TeV to be compared with the conjectured gluoniums with masses 3.6 TeV and 8.6 TeV.
What about the lepton pairs produced in the decay of Z
79. Do they also correspond to dark virtual leptons for M
G,79? For electrons the mass would be scaled by factor (2
127-79)/2= 2
24 to 8 TeV. For the muon, having mass of 106 MeV, the scaling would be (2
113-79)/2= 2
17 and give a mass of 13.2 TeV. The most plausible option is that the decay occurs directly
to an ordinary lepton pair.
Another option is that it occurs by p-adic cooling (see this and this) as a cascade leading from MG,79 to the p-adic prime characterizing the lepton; p-adic length scale and the value of heff are both reduced in steps which correspond to a single octave so that the geometric scale of lepton stays the same all the time.
3. Further questions raised by the proposal
In the sequel further questions inspired by the proposed explanation of B anomaly are considered.
3.1. Can the real t quark have mass of 28 GeV and be invisible in the decays of weak bosons?
Aleph anomaly corresponds to a meson mass about 56 GeV. In some earlier articles (see this
this
and this), this mass was erratically identified as the mass of the "real" t quark. If the meson in question corresponds to a top pair and mass is additive, the mass of top quark would be 28 GeV. If mass squared is additive, the mass of the real top would be about 40 GeV.
The assumption about low mass top quark seems to be in conflict with empirical facts as Martin Ebner found. A quark of this mass that is the partner of b under W, with the standard coupling, is the top quark lighter than W that the experiments searched for around 1990, and they excluded it: UA2 at CERN gave a lower limit of 69 GeV for its mass, CDF at Fermilab one of 91 GeV. W boson would decay into this quark and b in about a tenth of the cases, and its width would be about 2.3 GeV, where 2.14 +/-0.05 GeV is measured.
- Google Gemini informs that for 28 GeV mass, the increase of W decay rate would increase 27.5 per cent and 10.9 per cent for 56 GeV mass. The matriz element Vtb of the CKM matrixcan be reduced to make the decay rate to t-b pair small. One should have Vtb=∑iUit*Dib ∼ 0. For Utt 1 and Dbb ∼ 1 so large a destructive interference does not seem to be possible.
- This would not however help. Unitarity requires that the total decay rate remains the same. Google Gemini indeed informs us that this is the case. The change of the value of gW by such a large amount does not look realistic and the decay rates of W do not allow this.
It would seem that top with mass, say, 28 GeV must be there but is not visible. W bosons does not decay to tb pairs and Z boson does not decay to t pairs. How the Aleph quark as real t(28) quark could be there but would not be seen in W decays? If t(28) were dark in the sense of having a large value of h
eff for some reason, this would be the case. Could also t
t and t
bmesons be dark?
Even if the "official" top quark were the real one, one must explain why the exotic quark q associated with the Aleph anomaly (if indeed real) is not seen in the decay rates of W to q+b and of Z to q pair.
- There is an analogous problem related to lepto-hadrons (see this). There is evidence for lepto-pion-like states for all charged leptons. The identification as bound states of colored variants of leptons is the TGD inspired model. If the colored excitations are dark in the TGD sense, they cannot be produced in the decay of Z boson.
Could the interpretation of the Aleph anomaly in terms of color excitations of color triplet quarks be considered? Could the analog of leptopion be in question? The TGD view of color allows a lot of possibilities. The pion of M89 hadron physics has mass predicted to be about 70 GeV. However, ordinary pions have been reported to have resonance analogs both above and below its mass 140 MeV. Could also M89 pions have such excitations and could they include Aleph anomaly? This does not look plausible. However the darkness is what matters.
- Why the darkness? The general idea behind the hierarchy of Planck constants is that the Universe is theoretician friendly (see this). A transition to the dark phase makes perturbation theory convergent since coupling strengths are scale down by (ℏ/ℏeff)2. Also the transition to M89 physics that TGD assigns to the transition to quark gluon plasma would occur for this reason.
- t(28) is the most massive quark for M107? Could the TGD counterpart of quark-gluon plasma transition to M89 hadron physics occur for t(28) and give it a mass of 14 TeV so that it would disappear from the spectrum. In heavy ion collisions the transition to quark-gluon plasma takes place above sNN1/2 > 7.7 GeV. In proton-proton collisions cm energy energies in the 7-13 TeV range are needed. 28 GeV is above this energy but b quark mass 4.18 GeV is below it and would not be dark. This would conform with the proposal.
Here it is important to notice that in the TGD framework CKM mixing is between different fermion genera having the same p-adic length scale so that the same mixed state can appear in different mass scales, say that corresponding to M
107 or M
89 hadron physics. The the CKM matrix is not between different mass values but between different genera with the same value of p-adic mass squared having interpretation as conformal weight (see
this) and
this).
3.2. Is lepton universality violated in B meson decays?
What about the reported evidence for the violation of the lepton universality. I have written about this from the TGD point of view (see this and this)? The decay rate to muon pairs was reported to be 15 percent lower than to electron pairs. Google Gemini however informs that the finding is now regarded as an experimental artefact.
TGD proposal was that the Z and W bosons be states in which different genera carry different weights. The 3 fermion genera would define a triplet for a dynamical symmetry analogous to SU(3), essentially the analog of flavor symmetry. Bosons as fermion pairs would form an octet and singlet of this symmetry. The states with vanishing genus-color quantum numbers would be analogs of neutral pion, eta and eta' mesons. The 3 mutually orthogonal g-color-neutral states would be superpositions of these basic states. If Z79 were superposition with coefficients (a+ε,b-&epsilon,c) satisfying a+b+c=0, orthogonal to the state (1,1,1) with fermion universality. The state would be proportional to (1+ε, 1-ε, -2) with ε >0 and determined by the 15 percent deviation, which is howewer believed to be an artefact.
There would also be a third state orthogonal to these states and proportional to (x,y,-x-y) with x/y= (-1+ε)(1-ε). This proposal is problematic for photons since it would mean that effective charges of fermion generations would be different. It is not clear whether it makes sense to assume that the superposition depends on the boson and that the photon is always a singlet with respect to g-color.
In the case of γ79 genus-dependent weights look problematic since the em charges of different fermion generation would be apparently different. This is because in the TGD based model the mesons are regarded as superpositions of fermion pairs associated with different generations.
3.3. Could the MG,79 weak physics emerge in a phase transition M89→ MG,79?
This would alter the coupling of the Z boson within the W loop and also the coupling of W. Could all electroweak bosons be dark MG,79 bosons this would be visible in the mass dependence of the loops.
What happens in the transition between different standard model copies is an interesting problem. I suspect that a phase transition rather than mixing is in question. One can take the phase transition from M107 to M89 as a role model. The transition would take place quantum criticality generating a dark M89 phase with heff scaled up by 512. One can imagine at least two options but the following first one looks the most plausible.
- Quantum criticality would be lost in p-adic cooling (see this and this). The most recent application is to the TGD counterpart of energy production in the Sun that would occur at the surface of the Sun (see this).
The p-adic mass scale would be reduced step by step, most naturally by octaves or half-octaves and decay to "virtual hadrons" characterized by this scale would take place. The value of heff would also reduce gradually so that the Compton lengths would not be affected. The process would be analogous to overheating followed by cooling without a dramatic compression.
- Second option that one can imagine is that first quantum criticality would be lost completely by a reduction of M107 p-adic length scale to M89 p-adic length scale, meaning a contraction by factor 1/512. After that explosive increase of the p-adic length scale by stepwise manner down to M107 would take place.
Similar picture should apply to the transition for M
89 electroweak physics to its M
G,79 variant.
- The emission of a Z79 or γ79 by virtual W boson with a mass of 2.88 TeV would result in the production of muon pairs. The decay to muon pairs correspond to final-state interactions; for the purpose of predictions, only the process leading to the emission of
Z79 or γ79 is relevant.
- The estimate for the mass of the emitted particle comes from the propagator of the new particle. The mass of Z would be too small. Z79 propagator with much larger mass would add to the additional small contribution of the ordinary Z. The additional contribution to the amplitude is proportional to m2(t)/m2Z79.
If t quark is the "official" t quark, the Mt2/M2Z79 = (0.175/2.88)2 = 3.7 × 10-3 provides the scale factor. If the "official" top quark is replaced by an "Aleph" quark (see this), an additional factor of 1/9 approximately equal to the mass squared ratio of Aleph quark and top quark emerges and gives a factor 4× 10-4.
- What about the propagator of γ79 if it has a very small mass (this is if p-adic mass calculations contribute to its mass only in the second order). If Z79 is nearly on mass- shell, its contribution is larger than that of γ79.
3.4 Can one talk about interference of different standard model physics?
The above picture raises the questions about what the leakage from say M89 standard model physics to that associated with MG,79 does mean.
- The proposal is that a leakage between different standard model physics occurs and corresponds to a phase transition involving over-criticality. At quantum criticality Compton lengths would not be changed but masses would be scaled up. The interpretation as a leakage means that one cannot assign different gauge bosons to M89 and MG,79 physics. Rather, the same bosons would be in different phases. Analogously, water in solid and liquid phase is the same water at chemical level.
- If this leakage occurs only at the probabilistic level, the scattering rates are weighted sums for the rates predicted by scaled variants of the standard model physics. If the rates are very nearly the same the total rate would not affect appreciably. It is however reduced by about 25 percent.
- The leakage could also occur at the level of scattering amplitudes: this makes sense in the TGD framework since the superposition would be realized at the level of WCW ("world of classical worlds"). This would make interference effects possible if the amplitudes have different phases. The probabilities defined by the amplitudes would sum up to unity. The phase difference between the coefficients might cause constructive or destructive interference. Could this relate to the negative sign in the C coefficient and the reduction of the decay total rate. Quantum superposition of scaled copies of standard model physics would be in question!
Acknowledgements: I want to thank Martin Ebner and Marko Manninen for spontaneous AI assisted help in the analysis of the B anomaly.
For a summary of earlier postings see Latest progress in TGD.
For the lists of articles (most of them published in journals founded by Huping Hu) and books about TGD see this.