https://matpitka.blogspot.com/2026/11/proof-of-riemann-hypothesis-might-have.html

Friday, November 20, 2026

Proof of Riemann Hypothesis might have emerged: but how to understand why it is true?

Facebook was full of posts telling about the AI assistedn proof of Riemann Hypothesis (RH). Below some comments of the claimed proof and also a TGD view of RH suggesting that conformal confinement, which is basic elenemnt of TGD and implies that total conformal weights as sums of complex conformal weights as zeros of Zeta are real integers, requires RH.

The value of the proof would be that it would show that the axiomatics behind it is enough to prove or disprove the theorem. In this sense it has deep mathematical value. Otherwise would be still asking whether an extension of axiomatics is needed to prove it to true or not. It is difficult to imagine practical applications. One must of course be very critical: so long a proof by AI known to make mistakes could contain an error.

Understanding of why RH is true, would be more important that a proof whose details no human can go through. An understanding in terms of a physical model is what comes in mind. Personally I have some touch to RH: Years ago I wrote an article with a modest title "A strategy for proving RH". To my surprise it was even published in Acta Mathematica Polonica (see this and this).

I try to remember what I have written and combine it with the recent view of quantum TGD.

  1. One can start from the idea was that the zeros of Zeta correspond to the zeros of a formally defined thermodynamic partition function of an arithmetic quantum field theory continued to complex s-plane.

    For Re(s)>1 the definition as a product of single particle partition functions labelled by primes makes sense. The logarithms of primes correspond to energies in arithmetic QFT with states labelled by primes. 1/s plays the role of temperature in 1/(1-p(-s)), ps= exp(log(p)s), defining Bose-Einstein partitition function for a mode labelled by p. log(p) is analog of energy.

    For Re(s)>1 the partition function converges. However, an analytical continuation gives it for Re(s)<1, where the interpretation as a Bose-Einstein gas fails since the product does not converge. A phase transition occurs at Re(s)= 1 would the boundary between these regions.

  2. Bose-Einstein condensate would be a possible interpretation for what occurs. Below Re(s)=1 the system might be a macroscopic quantum system with long scale quantum fluctuations. Zeta vanishes at the zeros and thermodynamical probabilities are normalized by dividing with Zeta so that they diverge at zeros. The probability interpretation fails. The description in terms of BE labelled by energy eigenvalues log(p) gas fails.
  3. There is however a problem: temperature 1/s is complex. In TGD one can however consider the interpretation of this partition function as a vacuum functional that exponent with a complex phase which corresponds to the complex temperature. Vacuum functional would vanish and its inverse would diverge. Quantum criticality is a possible interpretation.
  4. What could be the interpretation of the zeros sn=1/2+iyn of Zeta in this case?
    1. The roots could correspond to complex conformal weights. The real conformal weights 1/2+ n characterize N-S type representations of conformal symmetries and integer conformal weights n characterizes Ramond type representations.

      Also complex conformal weights are possible at single particle level. Conformal confinement as the condition that *total* conformal weights for n-particle states are real and therefore integers would give a justification for RH. If conformal weights with Re(s) different from 1/2 are allowed, the conformal confinement cannot be satisfied universally. Hence conformal confinement would imply RH.

    2. The strategy for proving RH interprets the roots in terms of single particle coherent states labelled by conformal weights. These are orthogonal to the vacuum state with s=0 implying that the state is zero of Zeta. An argument that the roots are at Re(s)=1/2 axis is developed but the the properties of Ramond and N-S representations motivate the RH.
    3. Hilbert-Polya conjecture identifies roots of Zeta as eigenvalues of Hamiltonian. The interpretational problem is that the eigenvalues are complex. In TGD the problem would be solved by complex conformal weights and conformal confinement.
    To sum up:
    1. There would be two phases with different description of single particle states. The energies log(p) would be replaced by complex conformal weights sn= 1/2+iyn below the critical lines Re(s)=1. This would serve as the physical counterpart for the duality between zeros of Zeta and primes p.
    2. Energy eigenvalues log(p) would be replaced by the roots sn of zeta as conformal weight and conformal confinement, stating that the sum of conformal weights is integer for physical states, would be true.

      This is actually just basic TGD. The duality is realized in number theoretic vision about TGD applied now at the level of particle physics.

    For a summary of earlier postings see Latest progress in TGD.

    For the lists of articles (most of them published in journals founded by Huping Hu) and books about TGD see this.

No comments: